How can light behave like a wave
Quantum object electron
Waves or particles?
according to R. Sexl: Matter in space and time
There are experiments with both light and electron beams, some of which can be explained more clearly with the wave model, the other with the particle model. But what is light or electron radiation really? Wave or particle? A physicist formulated this dilemma for light almost resignedly: "On Monday, Wednesday and Friday the light is a wave, Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday it is a particle and on Sunday it rests."
In his book "Matter in Space and Time", Roman Sexl lists various approaches as to how one could cope with the dilemma:
- There are contradictions in nature that one has to live with. The contradicting wave properties and particle properties are examples of this.
This somewhat fatalistic approach is not pursued any further. It is more plausible to look for contradictions in our theories about nature than in nature itself.
- It is useful to sometimes prefer one model and sometimes the other. Other models may be necessary to explain other phenomena.
This unrelated juxtaposition of models that are not combined into a unit by a superordinate theory will not be pursued any further.
- There is a superordinate theory (quantum physics) which is suitable for describing the elements of the micro-world (quantum objects). The terms wave and particle are based on our “macroscopic” experience. Neither our senses nor our language can adequately grasp the micro-world. The very indistinguishable, strongly mathematically oriented and meanwhile extremely successful quantum theory cannot be mastered with the mathematical means available to us. In the sense of the curriculum, however, a little insight into the world of thought of quantum physics should be attempted at this level.
In this context, the famous physicist and Nobel Prize winner Richard FEYNMAN should be quoted:
In very small dimensions things behave like nothing of which we have direct experience. They don't behave like waves, not like particles. . . or anything we've ever seen.
The picture of modern physics is largely determined by quantum theory. That even great physicists had bigger problems with this theory (at least initially) is shown by the following quotes, which are somewhat comforting for us "normal consumers".
|Albert Einstein (1879-1955): |
Richard FEYNMAN (1918 - 1988)
Max BORN (1882 - 1970)
Nobel laureate Born wrote in a letter to Einstein: "The quanta are a hopeless mess."
Niels BOHR (1885 - 1962)
"When Einstein sends me a radio telegram that he has now finally proven the particle nature of light, the telegram only arrives because the light is a wave."
Illustrations on this page:
Albert EINSTEIN: by Ferdinand Schmutzer [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
- Which artist sang the song Nation Anthem
- What is the best SAS online training
- What a job almost anyone could do
- How long does it take for cryptocurrencies to disappear
- SEARCH ENGINE UPDATES 1
- What was your last traditional book
- How can my pimple be removed
- Are corn tortillas healthy
- Who likes to swim fully clothed
- What are NASA's future goals
- How is the Japanese city in Vietnam
- Can the Internet be provided via radio waves
- Why can't there be wars
- How do you get distanced?
- How was your experience with Brave Browser
- Which company makes the best valve amplifiers
- Has anyone pretended to have their GED?
- Self-documented code is mostly nonsense
- How are drugs regulated
- How to use text for columns
- How did Volcom get its logo?
- Is Toulouse safe at night
- What kind of organic molecules are enzymes
- Who is Australia trading with
- Was Descartes secretly an atheist
- How do judgment and judgment differ?
- What is french
- What is the highest package at MMU
- How can I scream my heart out
- Are there psychologists and therapists in Japan?
- What does Israeli dance look like
- Can we see music
- Why is silky straight hair more desirable?
- New York is destroyed